When a page has yet to be published, it has text next to it which says "unpublish". I took this to mean that this was a page I accidentally published before I meant to, and that this text was a button to remove the page from being published.
I would recommend changing this text from "unpbulish" to "unpbulished" or maybe even just "draft" so that there is no confusion on whether or not the page is live
Thank you Freya for the feedback. We are gonna revamp the Dashboard design this month, so this issue will be solved as well!
I would like to thank you for your suggestion on improving GemPages' User Experience.
I've well-noted it down and will discuss with the team on when is the appropriate time to develop it.